Which cloud sites are best for photos?

There are as many opinions for cloud sites that will store and share your photos.  Here some of are our favorites and their costs as of March 2020, with added focus of how well they "share" photos and photo albums, which is core to use with Collectionaire.

We believe Google Photos is best

We’ve been testing many photo cloud sites for two years, and while most all of the photo cloud sites work very well with Collectionaire, we’ve come to the conclusion that Google Photos is perhaps the best site to recommend to users who have not yet started with a cloud photo site. It's a robust, easy-to-use site with remarkable search capabilities, giving you the ability to quickly and easily curate your photos and create beautiful digital albums.

But it’s not perfect, for although you can change the “date taken” within the app, this data is not then embedded in the actual photo if it is then exported from the app.  It is for this reason that we suggest either first correcting this "date taken" data, or using a site like MemoryWeb, Forever, or other cloud program for those photos that do not have correct dates as they will embed this data in the photo. This date issue is most often found with scanned or heritage photos. 

Also, some users are concerned about Google and privacy (we are not. Here’s a good article: Is Google Photos private? ).

Here’s are a few of the reasons we recommend it:

  • Easy to add to your phone and upload all photos and videos and synchronize on all connected platforms
  • Free unlimited storage for all your photos (to be limited to 15GB on June 1, 2021). But photos uploaded before then are free to stay there. See note at the very bottom of this page for clarification on cost changes.)
  • Full size photo storage if you purchase a Google Cloud subscription
  • Lots of smart AI features such as facial recognition and auto-generated albums

Added benefits for use with Collectionaire:

  • Super easy to create and add to Shared Albums for indexing in Collectionaire, and can include video snippets
  • Google Photos albums provide a thumbnail photo for your Collection pages

Cost: Free, unlimited storage for photos up to 16 megapixels and videos up to 1080p resolution.  (Great for photos and short videos. Not sure about long-form home movies but doubt it at this point.)

Other Good Photo Sites

    MemoryWeb - An excellent photo storage platform.  It's especially good for older heritage or scanned photos as one can add metadata to the photo through the program itself. We use MemoryWeb for scanned photos and Google Photos for those with dates embedded when the photo was taken.

    • Metadata added to photo in app stays with photo (awesome feature)
    • Allows approximate dates
    • Sort photos by year and month
    • Easy to create and share Albums
    • Easy to sort Albums by date and date added
    • Search includes file name, caption, people, location or album (keyword coming soon)
    • A heritage photo with can be set to "flip" back and forth showing the image and any writing on the back (awesome feature).

    Less good:

    • Can't store videos
    • Can't rotate photos within app.
    • Does not allow full screen views or ability to zoom in on a photo

    iCloud Photos - iCloud is obviously used by tens of millions of users and works very well with Collectionaire. 

    • Good facial recognition and AI features
    • Allows photos and videos
    • Good presentation
    • Good automatic backup of photos and syncing on all connected platforms
    • Metadata can be exported with photo
    • Good slide show algorithm which we see as the best single feature of any cloud photo app

    Less good:

    • It takes a few more steps to create Shared Albums for use in Collectionaire
    • Shared Albums are listed in the order created... most recent first.  If one has dozens of Shared Albums it can become harder to organize them.
    • It won’t provide a preview thumbnail image and needs to be created separately (but quite easy at about 10 seconds per image once you do a few).

    Flickr - Flickr is an excellent photo storage site that works very well with Collectionaire.  It has all the basics…

    • Great presentation of photos and albums
    • Allows upload of photos and short videos
    • Good sharing and provides thumbnail and share links

    Less good:

    • Primarily designed for professional photographers rather than private family use.
    • No facial recognition or other AI features
    • Organization makes it sometimes difficult to manage

    Cost:  If more than about 1000 photos, you'll need a Pro account, which is about $50/year as of this post.

    Forever - An excellent photo storage platform. 

    • Metadata added to photo in app stays with photo
    • Search photos by year, month and tag
    • Easy to create and share Albums
    • Easy to sort Albums by date and date added

    Less good:

    • Allows storage of videos but they can't be viewed without downloading unless user pays an additional monthly fee.

    Amazon Photos – Amazon offers free unlimited photo storage for Prime members.  Many love the site.  It seems nearly identical to Google Photos but we simply haven’t been testing it long enough to delineate features.  We'll update this as we get more info.

    OneDrive - This is an excellent all-purpose site used by many Collectionaire subscribers.

      Shutterfly - Primarily created it seems for creating personalized gifts, it's actually a great site to create shareable albums and manage your photos.

      • Easy ot upload and can pull in photos from Google Photos, Facebook and Instagram
      • Albums easy to create and can be sorted by date uploaded and alphabetically
      • Photos viewed via shared albums are full screen and beautiful

      Less good:

      • Can't upload videos, and these days short videos are a big part of your photo collection.
      • We don't know if their metadata when added within the app can be exported with a photo, but it appears the photo date does not get embedded into the "Date Taken" field.

      DropBox - This is a general-purpose cloud site, somewhat like Google Drive or Amazon Drive, but is still an excellent photo storage site that works well with Collectionaire.  It has all the basics…

      • Good presentation of photos and albums
      • Good organizing and sharing features
      • Good automatic backup of files

      Less good:

      • Does not provide thumbnail images for Albums so these need to be generated manually

      SmugMug – SmugMug has many great features, as noted below. For use with Collectionaire we have only one concern. SmugMug is the only cloud photo site wherein if you change the location of a Gallery, the share link also changes. In these cases you'd need to recreate and reenter the link, which can be frustrating.  But with a good and disciplined system to not change links (we recommend such in our help section SmugMug – Creating Galleries and Share Links), this can be a great photo site for Collectionaire.

      • One can easily "mimick" their nested folder structure found on a computer or hard drive by simply dragging folders into the Upload area. 
      • Very easy to create Galleries (their term for Albums or Shared Albums) and link these albums to Collectionaire. 
      • You can also easily move or copy images from one Gallery to another.  And there are many other great features. 

      Permanent.org - A promising new photo cloud site.

      • Easy to create
      • Easy to sort Albums
      • Allows storage of videos

      Less good

      • if you share an album, the guest viewer MUST first create an account with Permanent.org before they can view your album. This is a significant drawback.

      Other Cloud Storage Options

      For your photos, we highly recommend using a site dedicated to photos, such as those noted above, rather than a general purpose cloud storage and sharing site such as Google Drive, Amazon Drive, Box, etc.  While some of these sites are the best sites for managing your home movies, they do not have the rich presentations and photo-centric features of those sites noted above.

      Please see the Help & Support topics in this Category for options.


      Google Photos price change info, per CNet in Nov 2020:

      Google Photos is ending its unlimited free storage policy for photos and videos, Google said Wednesday in a blog post. After June 1, 2021, any new photos and videos you upload will count toward the free 15GB of storage that comes with every Google account. But don't worry: Any photos or videos you've uploaded before that day won't be part of the cap. 

      The move is meant to encourage people to sign up for Google's storage subscription service, Google One. Google One plans start at $2 a month in the US for 100GB of storage and other features, like Google Store discounts.